BREAKING NEWS: Former Toronto Blue Jays Major League Baseball head coach John Gibbons now with bench coach for the New York Mets, sent a message to Toronto Blue Jays baseball head coach John Schneider concerning his…see more

In a moment that caught the attention of both Toronto Blue Jays and New York Mets fans alike, former Blue Jays manager and current New York Mets bench coach John Gibbons has sent a heartfelt — and slightly pointed — message to current Toronto skipper John Schneider, addressing the team’s recent performance struggles and the state of the franchise he once led.

During a postgame media availability with Mets reporters, Gibbons was asked about the Blue Jays’ current season, which has been marred by inconsistency, underperformance from star players, and increasing pressure on Schneider.

“Look, I love Toronto. Always will,” Gibbons said. “It’s a great baseball city, and those fans deserve a winner. I know it’s tough right now, but sometimes you’ve gotta shake things up or refocus — whatever it takes. I’m rooting for John [Schneider], but I’d be lying if I said I haven’t been watching closely.”

A Veiled Warning or Veteran Support?

Gibbons, who managed the Blue Jays in two separate stints (2004–2008, 2013–2018), is a beloved figure among Toronto fans for his no-nonsense approach, relaxed demeanor, and postseason success — leading the team to back-to-back ALCS appearances in 2015 and 2016.

His comments, while seemingly supportive, sparked speculation that Gibbons may be subtly questioning leadership direction in Toronto or hinting at dissatisfaction with the current state of the roster’s energy and accountability.

“I know what it takes to win there,” Gibbons continued. “It ain’t easy. But sometimes, a team just needs to find its heartbeat again.”

Blue Jays Fans React

Social media quickly lit up following Gibbons’ comments. Many fans interpreted it as a wake-up call to the Blue Jays front office and a possible vote of confidence in Schneider, while others wondered whether Gibbons — who remains a fan favorite — might be open to a return to Toronto if leadership changes occur.

“John Gibbons still cares. You can hear it in his voice,” wrote one fan on X. “Bring him back before the season’s lost. #FireSchneider #BringBackGibby”

Others took a more balanced view:

“It’s not about replacing Schneider. It’s about Gibbons reminding this team of its identity. He knows what this team can be.”

Schneider Responds

When asked about Gibbons’ comments, Schneider responded with class:

“I respect Gibby a ton. He’s a big part of this organization’s history. I take every word from guys like him seriously. We’re working every day to get this turned around.”

What’s Next for Toronto?

With the Blue Jays hovering near the bottom of the AL East and trade rumors swirling around key players, Gibbons’ message could add pressure — or serve as a rallying cry.

For now, one thing is clear: John Gibbons may be in New York, but his heart — and eyes — are still very much in Toronto.