BREAKING NEWS: St Louis Cardinals rumors: 2 players Nolan Gorman and Brendan Donovan with ‘no…..see more
⚾ Nolan Gorman – On the Roster Bubble
Demotion & Performance: Gorman began the 2025 season slumping (.203 BA, 37.6 % strikeout rate in 2024), prompting a mid-season demotion to Triple-A for adjustments . He also hit the injured list briefly in April with a hamstring issue .
- Trade Buzz: MLB.com and FanSided flagged Gorman as a potential trade chip if STL looks to retool at midseason . Analysts suggest his strikeout-heavy approach and crowded infield (with Arenado, Donovan, Burleson, etc.) could push the Cards to move him
- Defensive Logjam: With Nolan Arenado firmly at third base during spring training, Gorman would be displaced – likely relegated to second base or outfield roles, or possibly the bench
- Outlook: While Gorman’s raw power remains intriguing, his fit in the Cardinals’ 2025 plans remains uncertain. He’s on the fringe of the roster unless he regains offensive consistency.
🧩 Brendan Donovan – Arbitration & Trade Radar
- Arbitration Talks: Donovan filed for arbitration this offseason (requested ~$3.3 M, Cardinals offered ~$2.85 M) and ultimately lost
- Trade Considered: The Yankees have circulated rumors involving Donovan and their need for a defensive-minded infielder/outfielder Simultaneously, analysts note STL might include him as a trade asset down the line to manage roster depth .
- Cardinals’ Perspective: Donovan continues to be a key utility piece—leading the team in batting average and OPS in 2024 (.278/.342/.417), earning a Gold Glove and maintaining elite contact rates The consensus: he’s more likely to stay than go.
📊 Summary Table
| Player | Situation |
|---|---|
| Nolan Gorman | On thin ice—underperforming offensively, logjam behind Arenado, potential AAA platoon or trade candidate midseason. |
| Brendan Donovan | Solidified utility man—underwent arbitration (lost), Yanks interest exists, but Cards likely value him for depth and versatility. |
🧭 Final Take
- Gorman: The Cardinals are weighing their options. He remains a live trade candidate if he can’t rebound—especially with spring training offering limited positional room.
- Donovan: A safe bet to stay in STL through at least 2025, serving as a key utility piece—even as arbitration tension simmers.
Post Comment